Comparing 3D Printing Materials: How to Choose the Right Filament for Your Project

Comparing 3D Printing Materials: How to Choose the Right Filament for Your Project

Looking to print a phone stand that won't snap the moment you use it? Or perhaps a garden plant marker that can actually survive the sun and rain? If so, you’ve probably hit the ultimate maker's dilemma: Which filament is actually right for the job?

PLA, PETG, ASA, ABS, TPU ... sounds like a trip back to chemistry class at first, doesn't it? But don't worry - here you will not only find out what the materials can do, but which one you really need for your project - including practical tips, printing instructions and honest recommendations! We'll show you which filament you really need for your everyday life, how it behaves during printing and what you should definitely look out for in terms of temperature, outdoor suitability and durability. Ready to find the perfect material for your next project? Then let's shed some light on the filament darkness together!

PLA, PETG, ASA, ABS, TPU… it sounds like a flashback to chemistry class in school, doesn't it? But don’t worry - we’re here to break it down. We’ll show you exactly what these materials can do and which one your specific project actually demands. We'll cut through the jargon and give you practical tips, print settings, and honest recommendations. From temperature stability and outdoor durability to ease of use, we’ll help you find the filament you need for your everyday builds. Ready to stop the guesswork and start printing with confidence? Let’s shed some light on the "filament mystery" together!

The most popular 3D printing materials at a glance

► PLA - the uncomplicated all-rounder for beginners

PLA (polylactide) is the "feel-good" filament among 3D printing materials. It is very easy to print, produces beautiful surfaces and forgives minor errors. With no warping, no odour, and no drama, PLA allows you to just get on with printing.

What makes PLA stand out:

  • It prints easily with virtually no warping.
  • Superb adhesion - it sticks perfectly to PEI, glass or with glue stick.
  • You don't need an enclosed build chamber.
  • No harsh smells.
  • It is made from renewable raw materials.

The Catch: PLA is heat-sensitive. A temperature of just 60°C (like the inside of a car ona sunny summer day) is enough to deform your component. So avoid using it for outdoor projects.

💡 Pro Tip: If you still want more strength, use PLA+ or Tough PLA - these materials are almost as easy to print, but can withstand much more.

Typical Applications: Decorative objects, figurines, prototypes, housings, simple indoor brackets, etc.

► PETG - the all-rounder for robust components

PETG is the perfect middle ground between PLA and ABS. It is almost as easy to print as PLA but significantly tougher and more durable. Because it is both UV and water-resistant, it is the ideal candidate for outdoor use. PETG strikes the ultimate balance between stability and weather resistance. It retains its shape even in the peak of summer on the patio or in the garden. Unlike more brittle materials, it doesn’t splinter and handles post-processing well (such as drilling, sanding, or painting).

Distinguishing features of PETG:

  • It is stable, tough, weather-resistant and retains its shape even in the summer heat.
  • It is UV and water resistant.
  • Very good impact resistance.
  • Relatively easy to print.
  • Very good adhesion to PEI or glass, glue stick can be used if required.
  • Hardly any warping, very tough and flexible surface

The Catch: PETG is prone to stringing. However, with a bit of retract fine-tuning and a cooling fan at 50-70%, you can easily get this under control.

💡 Pro Tip: If your project involves tensile or bending stress - like custom brackets for the workshop or garden - PETG is virtually unbeatable. Plus: if you want components with optical clarity, transparent PETG delivers stunning, glass-like results.

Typical Applications: Functional parts, brackets, fixtures, workshop tools, outdoor projects, etc.

► PCTG - the premium all-rounder with extra toughness

If you’re already a fan of PETG, you’re going to love PCTG. Think of it as the "next generation" of PETG, boasting superior impact resistance, higher heat stability, and even stronger layer adhesion. It is rapidly becoming the professional alternative for applications that truly need to withstand heavy-duty use.

What makes PCTG stand out:

  • Significantly tougher than PETG - perfect for components under high mechanical stress.
  • Heat-resistant up to approx. 80-90°C (for PETG, it's around 70°C).
  • Outstanding chemical resistance, e.g. oils and cleaning agents.
  • Excellent layer adhesion and virtually no warping.
  • Excellent optical clarity - a great choice for transparent prints.
  • Strong layer adhesion to the build plate - a flexible PEI bed is worth its weight in gold here.

The Catch: PCTG is somewhat more sensitive to cooling - excessive fan speed can actually weaken the layer adhesion.

💡 Pro Tip: If you regularly print functional parts that need to absorb shocks or handle slight bending without snapping, PCTG is your sturdier upgrade to PETG without the notorious printing headaches of ABS.

Typical Applications: Functional components, brackets, mechanically stressed objects, technical prototypes, etc.

►ABS - The industry standard for demanding applications

ABS is a true industrial classic - countless everyday products (most famously LEGO bricks) are made from this material. It is exceptionally impact-resistant, heat-stable, and durable. However, it requires a higher level of technical know-how to print successfully.

ABS is the material of choice when you need functional parts that can take a beating. Because it is prone to shrinking as it cools, maintaining a consistent temperature in the build chamber is critical. A unique advantage: ABS can be vapour-smoothed with acetone, allowing you to achieve high-gloss surfaces with zero visible layer lines.

Features of ABS:

  • It can withstand temperatures of up to 100°C.
  • It is highly resistant to impacts and stress.
  • Adhesion spray is recommended for adhesion.
  • Handles post-processing well (drilling, sanding, acetone smoothing).

The Catch: ABS is notorious for warping and cracking. Printing it successfully without an enclosed build chamber is very difficult. Additionally, it releases a strong odour during printing - not a good choice for those who are sensitive to smells.

💡 Pro Tip: If you want the stability without the hassle, give ASA a try. It's the more modern version and much less fussy.

Typical Applications: Mechanical parts, vehicle components, tools, etc.

► ASA - the weather-resistant upgrade to ABS

ASA is essentially the "smarter" version of ABS. It offers the same legendary toughness but with the added benefit of being UV and weather-resistant. It withstands sun, rain, and wind without breaking a sweat and, unlike ABS, it won't turn yellow over time.

Why you should choose ASA:

  • High UV resistance (does not yellow outdoors).
  • High heat resistance: up to approx. 95°C.
  • Virtually no warping and good bed adhesion.
  • Adhesion spray or PEI is recommended for good adhesion.
  • Good layer adhesion, hardly any shrinkage.

The Catch: Closed build chamber is a great advantage and prevents cracking.

💡 Pro Tip: If you need strength and weather-resistance without the constant battle with ABS, ASA is your friend.

Typical Applications: Outdoor applications, car accessories, durable mounts, etc.

► TPU - the flexible filament with a rubber-like feel

TPU is the go-to material whenever you need elasticity. It can be bent, stretched, and compressed, and always returns to its original shape. With TPU, you can print rugged, flexible parts, ranging from vibration dampeners and cable tidies to drive belts and phone cases.

Unique features of TPU:

  • Flexible & wear/abrasion resistant.
  • Shock-absorbing.
  • Resistant to chemicals.
  • Adheres very well to PEI or glass.
  • Direct drive is recommended, slow printing (~30 mm/s) and reduced retract are a must.

The Catch: Ensure that your extruder is designed for use with flexible filaments, as otherwise the material can buckle and cause a jam in the feeder.

💡 Pro Tip: TPU filaments come in different hardness levels, measured on the Shore A scale. The lower the number, the softer the material. Shore 95A and relatively easy to print, while Shore 85A is significantly more "rubbery".

Typical Applications: Mobile phone covers, vibration dampeners, seals, shoe soles, etc.

► Nylon - the heavy-duty beast for tech enthusiasts

Nylon is incredibly strong, resilient, and virtually indestructible - but it is also demanding. If you are looking to print technical components that need to withstand real-world mechanical stress, nylon is unbeatable.

What nylon can do:

  • Exceptional tensile strength and abrasion-resistance.
  • Remains slightly flexible - does not break easily.
  • Superior layer adhesion.
  • Best used with a glue stick to ensure good adhesion.

The Catch: Nylon is highly hygroscopic - it sucks up moisture from the air like a magnet. Even a single day of exposure to air is enough to make it print like popcorn. This leads to bubbles and a poor surface finish. Therefore: Always dry nylon before printing! Also, be prepared for high print temperatures and potential warping.

💡 Pro Tip: Nylon is perfect for combining with carbon fibre or glass fibre - these composites result in ultra-sturdy, high-performance filaments.

Typical Applications: Gear wheels, hinges, machine components, etc.

► PC - the high-performance material for extreme loads

When maximum stability is non-negotiable, PC is the undisputed choice. It is an industry standard for parts that must withstand high temperatures, heavy impacts, and constant mechanical stress. In the world of 3D printing, PC represents the "heavyweight class" of filaments: exceptionally strong, heat-resistant, and virtually indestructible.

What makes PC stand out:

  • Extremely high impact resistance - virtually unbreakable.
  • Heat resistant up to approx. 110-120°C.
  • Exceptional rigidity and retains its shape.
  • Available as translucent or crystal clear - ideal for functional designs.
  • Chemical resistant: to oils, greases and many solvents.
  • Closed build chamber with a constant warm temperature (over 50°C) is recommended.

The Catch: PC is a material for advanced users. It needs high temperatures and a controlled printing environment; otherwise, it is prone to severe warping and layer separation. This means an enclosed build chamber is almost mandatory. Your print bed should be capable of reaching at least 100°C. The adhesion should be strong - e.g. use a special adhesive or PC build plate. PC also absorbs moisture quickly; this leads to bubbles and rough surfaces. Pre-print drying is a must!

💡 Pro Tip: If you are a relative novice but want to try printing with PC, choose PC blends instead (e.g. PC-ABS or PC-PBT). These are easier to print, but retain most of the structural stability of PC.

► PP - the rugged lightweight for special applications

PP (polypropylene) is one of those materials that might seem unassuming at first, but it’s actually everywhere in our daily lives - from food containers and hinges to automotive interiors and medical packaging.
In the world of 3D printing, PP stands out for its unique combination of flexibility, durability, and chemical resistance. It is incredibly robust and long-lasting, with the remarkable ability to be bent repeatedly without snapping.

What distinguishes PP:

  • High toughness & fatigue resistance - perfect for moving parts.
  • Very lightweight (one of the lightest printing materials).
  • Excellent chemical resistance to oils, greases & acids.
  • Slightly flexible - can be bent without breaking.
  • Closed installation space is recommended.

The Catch: PP is notorious for its poor adhesion to standard print beds. It sticks to almost nothing - except itself. That's why it works best on PP printing plates or special adhesive films, which are also made of PP. An enclosed build chamber helps minimise warping.

💡 Pro Tip: If you have trouble with bed adhesion, print on PP film or packaging tape - this ensures a super-strong bond and clean removal after printing.

Typical Applications: Technical parts, machine components, tools, drone parts, lighting covers, vehicle parts, etc.

►Composite filaments - wood, carbon, glass fibre & more

These special filaments combine standard materials (usually PLA, PETG or nylon) with fibres or particles such as wood, carbon or glass. They provide a unique finish or improve the mechanical properties of the material.

The power of composites:

  • Carbon fibre: lightweight & super strong.
  • Wood: natural look & matt surface.
  • Glass fibre: extremely stiff and temperature-resistant.

The Catch: These filaments are abrasive - a hardened nozzle is a must; otherwise your nozzle will soon break.

💡 Pro Tip: Composite filaments can be finicky during rectactions and layer changes - for the nest results, print slowly and evenly. And always check what kind of nozzle works best for the filament before you start printing!

Typical Applications: Design objects, prototypes, stable lightweight components, etc.

► PVA - the water-soluble support material for complex prints

Sometimes, a part is simply too complex to be printed with a single material. If you are printing models with deep cavities, intricate overhangs, or "print-in-place" moving parts, PVA (Polyvinyl Alcohol) is your best friend. As a water-soluble support material, it eliminates the need for mechanical removal. Simply submerge your finished print in warm water, wait a few hours, and the supports dissolve completely - leaving no residue and zero risk of damaging your model during "breakaway."

What makes PVA stand out:

  • Water-soluble - supports disappear in water without leaving any residues.
  • Very good adhesion to PLA and PETG.
  • Clean, smooth surfaces after removal.
  • Perfect for dual-extruder printers.

The Catch: PVA is extremely hygroscopic - it pulls water incredibly fast, which renders it unusable. Proper storage is therefore critical: always keep it in a dry place! (preferably in a dry box or with a dessicant such as silica gel). Additionally, avoid printing it too hot; excessive heat can cause it to "caramellise", leading to a clogged nozzle.

💡 Pro Tip: If you are printing support structures for high-temperature filaments (such as ABS or nylon), use BVOH or HIPS instead - they can withstand higher temperatures and dissolve in other liquids (e.g. limonene).

Typical Applications: Complex models with overhangs, mechanical components with moving joints, prototypes with internal channels or cavities, etc.

A Reality Check: Every filament is unique - even when they are made from the same material. Depending on the manufacturer, the specific chemical blend, and the additives used, you will see variations in printing behaviour, surface finish, and thermal stability. For instance, some PLA filaments are more heat-resistant than others, while PETG filaments can be tougher or shinier. Our advice is therefore to always check the manufacturer's recommended parameters for a filament before printing. Also, run a few test prints first. Taking these extra steps ensures you get the absolute best results from your chosen filament.

In a nutshell:

Applications recommended material why
Decoration, figures & models PLA easy to print, clean, rich in detail
Everyday parts & holders in the interior PLA+, PETG more stable and durable than standard PLA
functional parts & workshop objects PETG, PCTG impact-resistant, tough, durable
Outdoor projects ASA, PETG UV & weather resistant
heat-resistant parts ABS, PC, ASA dimensionally stable up to over 100 °C
flexible objects TPU rubbery, elastic
technical high-performance parts Nylon, PC, PC blend extremely stable, abrasion-resistant
lightweight & chemical-resistant parts PP flexible, resistant to chemicals
complex moulds with overhangs PVA water-soluble support structures
Design objects with special optics Wood, carbon and glass-filled filaments special haptics or elegant surface

Still unsure? Follow these simple golden rules:

  • New to 3D printing? → Start with PLA
  • Need something that can take a beating? → Go for PETG or PCTG
  • Is it going outdoors? → ASA is your best friend
  • Does it need to be flexible? → Choose TPU
  • Does it need to be virtually indestructible? → Choose PC or nylon
  • Need something lightweight & chemical-resistant? → PP
  • Complex gemetries or moving parts? → Use PVA as your support material
  • Looking for a premium aesthetic? → Wood or carbon-filled

Technical data sheets - your key to perfect print results

Hardly anybody enjoys reading technical documentation such as data sheets. But in the world of 3D printing, a Technical Data Sheet (TDS) is worth its weight in gold. Think of it as your filament material’s "ID card." It contains the DNA of your filament, providing the critical data you need to dial in your print parameters and realistically assess what the material can actually achieve. These figures aren't just for industry professionals. By understanding how a material behaves, you can make smarter choices, avoid failed prints, and save both time and money.

Every TDS contains a list of properties measured according to international standards (ASTM, ISO, etc.). While these values might look like dry statistics at first glance, they give you invaluable information about how your filament will perform on the print bed and in the real world. The section below explains the most important terms:

Flexural Modulus (E-Modulus) - Stiffness under bending: The higher this value, the stiffer the material. A filament with a high modulus of elasticity (e.g. PC, nylon CF) hardly bends at all and retains its shape - ideal for functional, load-bearing parts. A low value (e.g. TPU or PP): these are more flexible and pliable.

Flexural Strength - Resistance to bending until breakage: This indicates how much force the material can take during bending before it actually snaps.
This is relevant if you are printing parts that bend easily (e.g. brackets, levers). The higher the value, the more break-proof the material.

Tensile Strength: This shows how much "tugging" or pulling force a part can withstand before the material tears. A high value indicates it remains robust against tensile stress.

Tensile Modulus - Stiffness under tension: Similar to Flexural Modulus, but specifically for pulling forces. A high value here means the material will not stretch significantly when under a heavy load.

Elongation at Yield / at Break: This measures how much the material can stretch before it deforms (Yield) or snaps (Break). PLA often has < 10%, while TPU is > 300%. The higher this value, the more flexible and impact-resistant the filament is. At lower values, the material is brittle and more likely to break.

Notched/Unnotched Impact Strength: Describes how well the material can withstand sudden impacts - e.g. if your part falls. "Notched" means with a notch (weakest point), "Unnotched" means without. The higher the value, the more break-proof and impact-resistant.

VICAT - heat resistance: Indicates the point at which the material begins to soften under a load. This is the decisive value if your printed part needs to withstand heat - e.g. in a car or in the sun. At low values, the material deforms quickly; at higher values, the material remains stable.

Melting temperature: Indicates the point at which the material starts to flow. This helps you estimate the printing temperature - always stay slightly below this.

MFR (Melt Flow Rate) - flow behaviour: Describes how easily the molten material flows. High value = flows very easily (good for fine details), low value = viscous flow (better for stable layer adhesion).

HDT/B - Heat deflection temperature under load: Very similar to the VICAT specification, but more practical - describes when the material deforms under load.

Shrinkage rate: Indicates how much the material shrinks during cooling. The higher the shrinkage rate, the greater the risk of warping and warped prints.

Density: The higher the density, the heavier the material. This has an effect on weight and filament consumption - relevant for drone or lightweight components, for example.

💡 Practical Tip: If you are comparing multiple filaments and don't have time to analyse the entire data sheet, focus on these three values first: Tensile Strength, Vicat Temperature, and the Shrinkage Rate. Together, these three metrics provide the fastest snapshot of how a material will perform: its stability, heat-resistance and how easy it is print.

How to use this data in practice:

If you need this... then look for this... Reason
Robust components high tensile & bending strength more resilience
Flexible parts high elongation at break more elastic & impact resistant
Outdoor & heat-resistant parts high VICAT & HDT values does not deform in the sun
Fine details higher MFR flows better through the nozzle
Less warping low shrinkage rate remains dimensionally stable on the bed
Optically clean surface high hardness scratch-resistant & smooth

How to compare materials

Filaments differ not only in colour and price, but also in many other properties that will determine the success or failure of your print. With this overview, you can see at a glance which material is best where, and what its limitations are.

The stars incidate how well a material performs in a particular area. More stars = better performance. A material with ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ is therefore particularly strong or easy to print - one with ⭐, on the other hand, is more fussy or demanding. This allows you to quickly assess which filament is best for your project.

Property PLA PETG PCTG ABS ASA TPU Nylon PC PP
Printability ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐⭐
Strength ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐
Impact strength ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐
Flexibility ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Heat resistance ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐
Temperature resistance ⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐
UV/weather resistance ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐
Risk of warping low low low high medium low medium high medium
Post-processing very easy good good very good good difficult good good limited
Drying recommended necessary necessary recommended recommended necessary necessary necessary recommended

Even though the table shows typical properties, each filament can behave slightly differently depending on the manufacturer, formulation and colour additive. PLA is therefore not always the same as PLA. Some types are harder, others shinier or more heat-resistant. It is always worth taking a quick look at the technical data sheet of the respective filament - there you will find precise information on printing temperature, strength or heat resistance. This allows you to compare the values with your requirements and adjust the material perfectly.

Tip from the field

► If you are unsure how a material will behave during printing, make a calibration cube. Use a small test object to check whether the temperature, flow and layer are right. Saves filament and nerves.

temperature tuning is worthwhile. If you see threads → turn the nozzle down slightly. If layers adhere poorly → go a little higher.

always think about the environment in which your component will later be used:

  • Inside or outside?
  • Warm or cold?
  • Decoration or functional part?

► Observe the installation space temperature! Materials such as ABS, ASA or PC in particular do not like draughts - cover the printer (please do not use a cloth as this can be dangerous) and it is best to work with a closed housing.

► Clean print bed = half the success. Isopropanol works wonders. Greasy fingerprints or dust are often the cause of poor adhesion.

► Do not underestimate storage. Many filaments (e.g. nylon, PVA, TPU) absorb moisture from the air. Store them in airtight boxes with silica gel.

The more clearly you answer these questions and follow the tips, the easier it will be to find your material. And if you are wavering between two options: start with the simpler one (usually PLA or PETG) and work your way up step by step to the more challenging materials.

Conclusion: Your project, your material

Every filament tells its own story - and that's what makes 3D printing so exciting. Our tables and material descriptions give you a clear overview, but don't forget: the properties may differ slightly depending on the manufacturer, colour additive or formulation. A quick look at the technical data sheet will help you to better understand your filament and get the best out of your printer.

And if you're ever unsure - don't worry. The 3DJake team is always on hand with advice and experience. Whether you need tips on material selection, help with print settings or simply inspiration for your next project - we're here for you.

So: experiment, discover, grow with every print - and find your favourite filament. Because in the end, it's not just what you print that counts, but how much fun you have doing it!

Related products